A systematic review is an in-depth attempt to answer a specific, focused question in a methodical way.
Start with a clearly defined, researchable question, that should accurately and succinctly sum up the review's line of inquiry.
A well formulated review question will help determine your inclusion and exclusion criteria, the creation of your search strategy, the collection of data and the presentation of your findings.
It is important to ensure the question:
Is the research question justified?
To help in focusing the question and determining the most appropriate type of evidence consider the type of question. Is there is a study design (eg. Randomized Controlled Trials, Meta-Analysis) that would provide the best answer.
Is your research question to focus on:
If appropriate, use a framework to help in the development of your research question. A framework will assist in identifying the important concepts in your question.
A good question will combine several concepts. Identifying the relevant concepts is crucial to successful development and execution of your systematic search. Your research question should provide you with a checklist for the main concepts to be included in your search strategy.
Using a framework to aid in the development of a research question can be useful. The more you understand your question the more likely you are to obtain relevant results for your review. There are a number of different frameworks available.
A technique often used in research for formulating a clinical research question is the PICO model. PICO is explored in more detail in this guide. Slightly different versions of this concept are used to search for quantitative and qualitative reviews.
PICO = Population, Intervention, Comparison, Outcome
|Population, Patient or Problem
|Intervention or Indicator
|Comparison or Control
Who or what is the question about?
What is the problem you are looking at?
Is there a specific population you need to focus on?
Describe the most important characteristics of the patient, population or problem.
What treatment or changes are you looking to explore?
What do you want to do with this patient?
What factor may influence the prognosis of the patient?
Is there a comparison treatment to be considered?
The comparison may be with another medication, another form of treatment, or no treatment at all.
Your clinical question does not have to always have a specific comparison. Use comparison if you are comparing multiple interventions. Use a control if you are comparing an intervention to no intervention.
What are you trying to accomplish, measure, improve or affect?
What are you trying to do for the patient? Relieve or eliminate the symptoms? Reduce the number of adverse events? Improve function or test scores?
What results will you consider to determine if, or how well, the intervention is working?
|Population or Problem
What are the characteristics of the Population or the Patient?
What is the Problem, condition or disease you are interested in?
Interest relates to a defined event, activity, experience or process
Context is the setting or distinct characteristics
|Intervention, Exposure or Interest
Setting is the context for the question - where
Perspective is the users, potential users, or stakeholders of the service - for whom
Intervention is the action taken for the users, potential users, or stakeholders - what
Comparison is the alternative actions or outcomes - what else
Evaluation is the result or measurement that will determine the success of the intervention - what result or how well
|Phenomenon of Interest
Sample size may very if qualitative and quantitative studies
Phenomena of Interest include behaviours, experiences and interventions
Design influences the strength of the study analysis and finding
Evaluation outcomes may include more subjective outcomes - such as views, attitudes, etc.
Research types include qualitative, quantitative or mixed method studies
Improvement or information or innovation
At whom the service is aimed
Where is the service located?
Who is involved in providing/improving the service?
For which service are you looking for information?
This Library guide by RMIT University Library is licensed under a CC BY-NC 4.0 licence, except where otherwise noted. All reasonable efforts have been made to clearly label material where the copyright is owned by a third party and ensure that the copyright owner has consented to this material being presented in this library guide. The RMIT University logo is ‘all rights reserved’.